What are the competing arguments about the foundations of Australia?
There are a few competing arguments about the foundations of Australia. These include the possibility of a 'dumping ground' for convicts, an Empire/naval base in the strategic region of the Pacific, a possibility of opening up trade with Asian markets and lastly, the abundance of flax and timber which could be exploited and used for sails and masts.
The argument for a 'dumping ground' for convicts is a popular one, considering the prison crisis back in Britain, where there was little space left to hold criminals for an extended period of time. America had just established its independence and was refusing any more convicts be brought to their shores. Joseph Banks reported to the House of Commons that Botany Bay would be a suitable site for a penal colony in 1779. He suggested that escape would be 'difficult' and that after the first year they might be able to sustain themselves, given the fertility of the soil. He also mentioned that the natives would not be opposed to their presence there, as he saw very few whilst on his trip and suspected there to be only 'fifty in all the neighbourhood'. He also claimed that the climate was very similar to that of Toulouse in the south of France. With all of this in mind, the British government made the decision to transport their convict to Botany Bay. It is little wonder why the argument of a 'dumping ground' for convicts as a reason for the foundation of Australia is often thought the be the most likely one.
Another argument about the foundation of Australia is the strategic position within the Pacific Ocean for an Empire/naval base. This area was close enough the the Asian region to get there quickly if the situation arose, but far enough to not feel threatened by and tensions that may have been felt between the two parties. It was also an expansion of the Empire which was steadily growing. This argument is not considered to be the main reason for the colonisation of Australia, but it is still relevant in the foundation of the nation.
Trade with Asia is thought to be another reason for the foundation of Australia, as it it close by. Asian markets gave the British access to new sources of material, such as spices. Trade with Asian also gave the British a presence within the Pacific. Once established as a farming colony that could export materials such as meat and rice, Australian trade with Asia became very important to the economy. This argument for the foundation of Australia is again not thought to be the main one, however it has become more and more important over time.
The abundance of flax and timber was an enticing incentive to the British who were in need of a large source of naval materials which they could exploit. High quality flax and timber were as important to any naval entity back then, as oil is now. Unfortunately, the materials were not of a high quality and were not very conveniently located to Britain. Nevertheless, they remained a strong argument for the foundation of Australia at the time.
Though the argument for a 'dumping ground' for convicts seems the strongest one for the foundation of Australia, it seems likely that is was a combination of all of these reasons - expansion of empire, naval base, trade and an abundance of naval material, that were the reasons for the foundation of Australia.
This picture is relevant to this week's blog because it is an artist's rendition of the First Fleet arriving on Australian shores in 1788.
source of picture: http://www.lakemunmorah.ps.education.nsw.gov.au/onlineworksheets/stage_2/britishcolonisation.htm

No comments:
Post a Comment